Plumbing Lead Companies Compared (2026)
9 options checked against their own public pages: published prices, per-lead fees, contracts, and who owns the website.
See the comparisonUpdated Oct 2026 · Checked Oct 2026 · By Isaiah, plumber
Short answer: No single plumbing lead company is best. Marketplaces like Angi and Thumbtack sell leads (often shared); pay-per-call services like Service Direct and eLocal send exclusive calls; agencies like Scorpion and 99 Calls bundle websites and ads. Compare cost per booked job, contract terms, and who owns the site before signing.
How we checked
- We read each company’s own public pricing, FAQ or help pages in October 2026.
- If a company doesn’t publish something, we wrote “not published” instead of guessing.
- Where we used a third-party figure (like contractor-reported Angi prices), we say so and link it.
- We’re one of the options listed. We’ve tried to describe everyone, including us, the same way. We don’t sell leads and have no affiliate deals with anyone here.
- Prices and terms change. Always confirm with the company before you sign.
Comparison table
Scroll sideways on a phone. Checked Oct 2026.
| Company | Type | Published price? | Per-lead fees? | Contract | Who owns the site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Angi (HomeAdvisor) | Marketplace, pay per lead | No (source) | Yes; ~$40–$85 reported for plumbing ({c(‘lt’)}) | Not published; 12-month terms reported by third parties (source) | No site built |
| Thumbtack | Marketplace, pay per lead | No; you set your own prices (source) | Yes, price you set | No subscription fees (source) | No site built |
| Networx | Shared or exclusive leads | Range only: $10–$120+ (source) | Yes | No contract (source) | No site built |
| eLocal | Pay per call or lead | No; set with a rep (source) | Yes | No contract (source) | No site built |
| Service Direct | Pay per call | Range: plumbing $60–$255 (source) | Yes, price you set | No term contract (source) | No site built |
| Bark | Credits per lead | $2.35/credit; credits per lead vary (source) | Yes, in credits | Not published | No site built |
| 99 Calls | Agency plans + leads | Yes: $99–$4,999/mo plans (source) | On Growth plan, organic per-lead fee; amount not on pricing page (source) | No contracts, every tier (source) | Not published |
| Scorpion | Marketing agency | No; quoted per business (source) | Not published | Typically 12 months for website/SEO (source) | Domain, content, imagery yours after contract; site must be rebuilt elsewhere (source) |
| Home Service Site Shop (us) | Websites + Google profile help | Yes: sites from $299 + $49/mo; profile help $79/mo (source) | None | Profile management: no contract (source) | You own the domain and site |
“No site built” means the service sends leads or calls but doesn’t build you a website, so ownership doesn’t apply.
Each company in plain words
Angi (HomeAdvisor)
What it is: The big homeowner marketplace. Angi says it had over 1.5M opportunities last month.
Can fit if: You want volume fast and can respond within minutes.
Worth checking: Angi doesn’t publish per-lead prices; third-party reports cite a ~$300/yr membership and 12-month terms. Get your price and terms in writing.
Thumbtack
What it is: Marketplace where you set your own lead prices.
Can fit if: You do smaller, quick-turn jobs and like controlling your budget.
Worth checking: No subscription fees, but per-lead costs depend on your settings and market.
Networx
What it is: Shared or exclusive leads, matched to up to four pros.
Can fit if: You want a choice between shared and exclusive with no contract.
Worth checking: Published ranges are wide ($10–$100+ shared, $15–$120+ exclusive); check your exact category price in the dashboard.
eLocal
What it is: Pay-per-call and leads. Calls are exclusive; shared leads go to up to 4 businesses.
Can fit if: You want exclusive phone calls and a prepaid budget.
Worth checking: Prices are set with a rep, not published. Ask how credits for bad calls work.
Service Direct
What it is: Exclusive pay-per-call marketplace. You choose your price per lead.
Can fit if: You want exclusive calls and to control the price.
Worth checking: Plumbing ranges $60–$255 per lead, so track cost per booked job closely.
Bark
What it is: Lead marketplace using credits.
Can fit if: You want to see each lead’s cost before you respond.
Worth checking: Credits bought after Nov 1, 2025 expire 3 months after purchase.
99 Calls
What it is: Agency bundles: website, Google profile, ads management, CRM.
Can fit if: You want an all-in-one done-for-you package.
Worth checking: Growth plan adds a 15% ad fee and an organic per-lead fee; ownership of the site isn’t stated on the pricing page.
Scorpion
What it is: Full-service marketing agency with its own website platform.
Can fit if: You’re a larger shop wanting a full agency.
Worth checking: Typically 12-month contracts for website/SEO; you’d rebuild the site elsewhere if you leave.
Which type fits you?
| If you… | Look at | Keep an eye on |
|---|---|---|
| Need calls this week | Pay-per-call services | Cost per booked job |
| Do lots of small jobs | Marketplaces (Thumbtack, Bark) | Lead price vs. ticket size |
| Want everything done for you | Agencies (99 Calls, Scorpion) | Contract length, ad fees, site ownership |
| Want calls without paying per lead long-term | Your own website + Google profile | Takes months to build |
Plenty of plumbers mix these: paid leads to fill gaps while their own Google profile and website build up. There’s no wrong answer, as long as you track what each job really costs. Our plumbing lead cost guide shows the math, and how to get more plumbing calls covers the free stuff you can do yourself. If the last row sounds like you, start with plumber website design: which pages a plumbing site needs and what each plan costs.
Questions to ask any vendor before you sign
- What’s my exact price per lead or call for my zip code? In writing?
- Are leads shared? With how many other plumbers?
- Any setup fee, membership or monthly minimum?
- How long is the contract, and what does early cancellation cost?
- How do I get credit for wrong numbers, spam or out-of-area calls?
- Do prepaid credits or deposits expire?
- If you build my website: if I cancel, do I keep the domain and the site?
- Do you charge per lead for calls that come through my own website?
Shared leads, exclusive leads, and calls
These words show up on every vendor page:
- Shared lead: the same customer request goes to several plumbers. Cheaper per lead, harder to win. Published close rates run about 2–5% (Cited).
- Exclusive lead: only you get it. More per lead, but published close rates run about 25–45% (Cited).
- Pay-per-call: a live phone call routed to you. eLocal says its calls are always exclusive (eLocal).
How Site Shop helps (what we sell)
I once paid a lead company for about a year and got almost nothing back, which is why we built something different. Site Shop is not a lead company. Here’s exactly what we offer, and only this:
A website you own
Your domain, your content. Keep it if you leave.
Pages that bring calls
Service and city pages built to rank.
Google profile management
$79/mo, or $49/mo for Site Shop website clients.
No per-lead fees
One clear price. Every call is yours.
We don’t sell leads or manage ads. Websites start at $299 plus $49/mo maintenance and unlimited updates. It takes longer than buying leads, and that’s the honest trade-off. See plumber website design or the pricing page.
FAQ
What is the best plumbing lead company?
There isn’t one best for everyone. Pay-per-call services suit plumbers who want exclusive calls fast; marketplaces like Thumbtack suit smaller jobs; agencies suit shops that want everything done for them. Compare cost per booked job, contract terms and who owns the site.
Which plumbing lead companies publish their prices?
As of Oct 2026, Service Direct (source), Networx (source), Bark (source) and 99 Calls (source) publish prices or ranges. Angi, Thumbtack, eLocal and Scorpion don’t publish a fixed price.
Do plumbing lead companies require contracts?
Many don’t. Networx, eLocal and Service Direct say no contract on their own pages. Scorpion says it typically requires 12 months for its website and SEO services (source).
Who owns the website if a marketing company builds it?
It depends on the company, so ask in writing. Scorpion says you own your domain, content and imagery after the contract ends, but you’d need to rebuild the site elsewhere (source). Pure lead marketplaces usually don’t build you a site at all.
Are shared plumbing leads worth it?
They can be if you call back within minutes. Published figures put shared close rates around 2–5%, which raises cost per booked job (Cited). Our lead cost page has the math.
Sources (checked Oct 2026)
- Angi Pro sign-up · Smarter Outbound: Angi review · LeadTruffle: Angi costs (contractor reports)
- Thumbtack for Pros
- Networx: lead prices · Networx: contracts · Networx: contractor leads
- eLocal FAQ · Service Direct pricing · Bark credits
- Cited: plumbing lead costs
- 99 Calls pricing · Scorpion FAQ · Home Service Site Shop pricing
Spot something out of date? Email tradekitco13@gmail.com and we’ll fix it.